User:Salasay/FQA Drydocks

Collection of Featured and Quality Article nominees on my workbench for either improvement, finishing, or rejection.

Featured Article Drydocks[edit]

Talk:Scout (5e Class): Mine, so I'm obviously in favor and working to get it passed.
The rest of the current FAs seem okay, but are in categories I don't work in so I can't give much useful input.

Talk:Athame (5e Equipment): Mine, so I'm obviously in favor and working to get it passed.
Talk:Conjure Ammunition (5e Spell):From late 2020, consensus is Opposed. I agree with the opposition, but, I think it's salvageable.
Talk:Fencing Cloak (5e Equipment): From early 2020, consensus is Mixed, leaning strongly towards support. I've suggested some small improvements that I think will tip it into acceptance.
Talk:Greatbow (5e Equipment): From early 2020, consensus is Support. Penalty could be reduced from 20ft to 15ft.
Talk:Longspear (5e Equipment) and Talk:Long Cane (5e Equipment): An odd case, the former is a QA and the latter is a nominee. There's more detail on the talk pages, but the short of it is I think the Longspear needs to be reworked, and since doing so would make the Long Cane weirdly redundant it would also need a rework.
Talk:Minor Ward (5e Spell): From early 2022, consensus is Support. Could be upped slightly to 2/4/6/8 temp HP.
Talk:Perfect Striker (5e Feat): From late 2021, consensus is Mixed. I'm Opposed because I think it's uselessly weak, as it stands.

Talk:Cassia (3.5e Deity):This is a fairly old FA, and it's, er, definitely a product of its day. "Straw Feminist (The goddess)", with some questionable content that seems regrettably integral to its identity, I don't think this should be promoted by the wiki.

Talk:Bastard Sword, Variant (5e Equipment): From early 2020, consensus is Opposed. Item seems redundant.

Talk:Aalar (5e Deity): Fairly bland moon-god. Nomination isn't very old, so work could be done to it yet, but there's been no movement since its nomination so I find that unlikely. Will probably need to get dropped soon, especially in light of Mara's comment

Talk:Battlemage, Variant (5e Class): Nominated in 2020. I'm opposed to it, and it seems like that's the trend of the comments, but there's not enough of a consensus for me to confidently insist on that call.