User talk:Quincy/Phalanx

• Hit Die How can Hit Dice be "1D12 + Con mod + Phalanx level"?
• Armor Fighters are already proficient with all armor and shields. What is a "tower shield", do you mean the homebrew one on this website? What is the "penalty" referred to? What is an "armor penalty check"? Why does movement increase to 30 ft, what has this got to do with armor? Looks like this was written for 3.5e
• Weapons. What is this -5 penalty, 5e doesn't do this, you would use disadvantage instead. Does the shield count as a simple or martial weapon?
• Anchor Howl Do "foes" (use the term "creatures you choose") get a saving throw against this forced action? How long does the forced behaviour last for? What happens if you use the howl and then make yourself unavailable as a target?
• Incercept Could this not use the established mechanic for damage resistance? 5e does not have "immediate actions" (again you are thinking of 3.5e) this would be a reaction, which ought to be mentioned in the first sentence with exactly what the trigger is. How does this provide cover in a 15 feet cube? What does "behind you" entail for people not using the optional facing rules? "Encounter" is not a define duration, you would use "within 1 minute".
• Legendary Shield Master - what does "use the full AC of your off-hand shield" mean? What is this penalty for putting shields on your back? What does "victim to sneak attacks or disadvantage from behind" mean? Do I not already get my Strength modifier to my shield attack, since it is a melee weapon?
• Spell Shield Master - What does "immune to one type of magic and resistant to all others" mean? My shield can be immune to evocation damage and resistant to enchantments or something? How does that effect me? By "projectile spell" do you mean a ranged spell attack? "immediate action" again. If a spell is reflected, is the original attack bonus used, or something different? Mentions "facing" and "direction you can see", how does this work if you are not using the optional facing rules?
• Vampiric Shield Master What is "vampiric damage", shouldn't this be necrotic? I can repeatedly make attacks with my shield against inconsequential creatures to quickly regain all my hit points?
• Undying rage - How do you determine if you are "in good standing with your God(s)" and if they can hear you or not? Does this use an action? Half way through it mentions this is a spell, is this a spell? There is a standardized "1 minute" duration that should cover a combat encounter, extending beyond this is an unnecessary complication. What happens when you "lose 1 turn", are you stunned? Incapacitated? Marasmusine (talk) 18:07, 13 March 2016 (MDT)